GoldfishVSOscar Fish

Can they live together? Complete Compatibility Analysis

Compatibility Score

🚫 Do Not Mix

Goldfish and Oscars are fundamentally incompatible due to vastly different temperature requirements, significant size and aggression mismatch, and conflicting dietary needs.

Potential Issues

•Goldfish are coldwater (65-72°F) while Oscars are tropical (74-81°F). Keeping them at a compromise temperature stresses both species, weakening their immune systems.
•Oscars are large, aggressive predators that will view smaller goldfish as food. Even similar-sized goldfish will be relentlessly harassed and nipped.
•Oscars produce a high volume of waste, and goldfish are exceptionally messy. The bioload would be unsustainable in all but the largest, most over-filtered systems.

Tank Requirements

Temperature

Incompatible. Goldfish: 65-72°F. Oscar: 74-81°F.

pH Level

Goldfish: 7.0-7.8. Oscar: 6.5-7.5. Overlap exists but is irrelevant due to other factors.

Minimum Tank Size

Not applicable for mixing. Separately: Single Oscar requires 75+ gallons. Goldfish require 20+ gallons for the first, plus 10-20 gallons per additional fish.

About Goldfish and Oscar Fish

When considering adding Oscar Fish to a tank with Goldfish, it's crucial to understand their specific needs. Goldfish and Oscars are fundamentally incompatible due to vastly different temperature requirements, significant size and aggression mismatch, and conflicting dietary needs.

Key Differences

Goldfish: Requires 20 gallons minimum. Usually prefers coldwater water conditions.
Oscar Fish: Requires 55 gallons minimum. Usually prefers tropical water conditions.

Have a more complex tank setup?

Our AI calculator can analyze multiple species at once.

Try Full Calculator